If we imagine a situation in which a close friend comes to us, finding themselves in their own distress, we will likely try to help them and offer a shoulder to cry on. But if we imagine ourselves in a similar situation, we do not react the same way. We say words to ourselves that we would not dare say to our closest ones. Few people know how to approach themselves with the same self-kindness during times of trouble that they offer to others. We often mistakenly believe not only that we have made a mistake, but also that we ourselves are the mistake. Why is it so much more difficult for us to offer ourselves kindness and warm words, even though we hurt ourselves with our own criticism? This is precisely where the difference lies between the compassion we feel for others and self-compassion.

Self-compassion itself originates from compassion, whose healing properties have been described for centuries (Gilbert, 2009). The Tibetan philosopher, the Dalai Lama, spoke of compassion as a source of contentment and happiness. "If you want others to be happy, focus on compassion. If you want to be happy yourself – focus on compassion." (Dalai Lama, 2001). According to Wang (2005), compassion represents a modern neurohormonal network emerging from basic maternal instincts serving to protect the weak and vulnerable human individual. Achieving this difficult goal required the cooperation of several individuals, which was prompted precisely by the felt compassion for the vulnerable individual, leading to the mobilization of support from other clan members. Compassion means a willingness to approach the unpleasant emotions of a person in need of help. Compassion requires the determination with which we consciously notice suffering and pain, instead of looking away and avoiding these emotions. Compassion carries a shift of attention toward suffering combined with a desire to alleviate this distress (Gilbert, 2020).

The leading proponent of this concept is Neff (2023), who operationalized self-compassion as a two-dimensional construct consisting of self-compassionate and un-self-compassionate responding, with both dimensions comprising three components that reflect mutually contrasting poles (self-kindness vs. self-judgment, common humanity vs. isolation, mindfulness vs. over-identification). Self-compassionate responding is defined as the positive aspect of self-compassion, which includes warm behavior toward oneself, awareness of the fact that making mistakes is human, and also the non-judgmental observation of one's own thoughts and emotions. On the other hand, un-self-compassionate responding represents the absence of self-compassion, reflected by contrasting poles, which include self-critical behavior toward oneself, perceiving one's own mistakes and emotions as unique, and being consumed by one's own failure. When we see someone who is struggling and experiencing sadness or suffering, we are filled with a peculiar warm feeling – compassion. We can offer comfort and show support to others, but it is often much more difficult to show similar tenderness to ourselves. Research by Koroniová et al. (2020) suggests that compassion is a relatively well-known construct, whereas self-compassion is more or less unknown to people. It is much easier to receive compassion from a close person than to be compassionate toward oneself. Many people may find self-compassionate responding unnatural and difficult. At the same time, Baranková (2023) demonstrated significant difficulty in visualizing oneself as a figure that should offer us warm words. Mindfulness reflects the ability to be aware of one's own emotions with distance and a neutral, unbiased attitude, without judging ourselves for our feelings. In contrast to it, Neff's (2023) theory introduces over-identification, characterized by a state where, in times of distress, a person struggles with their own emotions that they do not want to acknowledge. Mindfulness teaches us to name our emotions and then accept the fact that they merely come and go, instead of maladaptively suppressing or ignoring them. Self-kindness reflects a kind way of expressing oneself toward oneself, similar to how we would react to a close person during a difficult period, or how we would want them to react toward us. Common humanity represents the awareness that every person has experienced similar moments of suffering and disappointment. This fact helps us feel less alone and isolated in our emotions and difficult times. Ultimately, each of us makes mistakes; it is part of the human experience. Neff (2023, p. 196) characterized common humanity with the statement: "We react as if something went wrong, and we forget that being human means facing challenges and being vulnerable."

According to Halamová et al. (2018), self-compassion, despite its many benefits, is still not perceived as socially desirable and acceptable. Even therapists themselves, who spread awareness about this construct, sometimes experience psychological barriers preventing them from engaging in self-compassion practices (Barton, 2019). Current knowledge indicates that self-compassionate responding brings many benefits, including protection against increased anxiety during stressful periods (Jiménez-Gómez et al., 2022), helps us learn to accept our own mistakes (Ferrari et al., 2018), and also strengthens interpersonal bonds (Šeboková & Filipčíková, 2020). The question remains, why do many people not treat themselves self-compassionately despite these many benefits? One of many explanations is the existing socially constructed stigma towards self-compassion and kind behavior towards oneself as such. Stigma reflects feelings of shame and devaluation; generally, we distinguish three types of stigma – social, structural, and internal (Moser, 2023). Self-compassion may be perceived by the general public as a sign of self-pity or excessive focus on oneself. These negative attitudes and opinions about self-compassion from society form the basis of social stigma. According to authors Chwyl et al. (2020), these negative beliefs about self-compassion can hinder its use. Authors Chwyl et al. (2020) demonstrated that people do not want to be compassionate towards themselves because they fear loss of motivation (“if I accept my shortcomings, I will become passive”), laziness (“if I am not strict enough with myself, I will never improve”), and irresponsibility (“if I stop blaming myself, I won’t change anything”). Individuals often feel that by showing self-compassion, they place themselves in the position of a victim who merely blames the world, remains passive, and settles for a good-enough result. A problem in society arises when individuals perceive self-compassion as weakness. Therefore, they will be reluctant to use it, and thus may be more prone to excessively self-critical responding. However, Chwyl et al. (2020) demonstrated that such negative beliefs about self-compassion can be manipulated in an experimental study. Respondents initially thought they were participating in research focused on goal achievement, but after random assignment to two groups, they had the opportunity to read two different versions of a fake magazine: (a) self-compassion promotes a healthy relationship with oneself and helps one learn from one’s mistakes; (b) self-compassion hinders growth and leads to weaker self-discipline. The authors demonstrated that participants who had the opportunity to read the magazine with a positive view of self-compassion showed higher scores in self-compassionate responding when asked to imagine how they would react to themselves during a hypothetical situation (e.g., I imagine I studied for an exam that I ultimately failed). However, if an individual internalizes negative beliefs and stereotypes arising from social stigmatization, self-stigmatization may develop, which subsequently manifests in their experience and behavior (Moser, 2023). Similarly, reluctance towards self-love may, in our opinion, also stem from early experiences in childhood and adolescence, during which parents primarily taught us how to react to our own failures. If an individual grows up in an environment that fosters coldness and self-criticism, it is not surprising if they carry these patterns of thinking and behavior into adulthood. Such a person may never have encountered the possibility of reacting to failure and their own mistakes in any way other than self-criticism.

Looking at it from another perspective, self-compassion may indeed seem to some like a selfish technique for coping with difficult times. It requires a certain level of self-love and gentleness towards oneself, which may not be pleasant or realistic for everyone. We believe that this is precisely where the true power of self-compassion lies. The reason is that at the moment when we are able to accept our mistakes and shortcomings, when we can think about ourselves without judgment, criticism, and unpleasant words, only then do we become stronger in a certain way. Prevailing social norms currently place greater emphasis on resilience and emotional coldness. Stereotypes and the overall view of self-compassion are also shaped by cultural and societal differences around the world. According to authors Montero-Marin et al. (2018), culture particularly influences how a person reacts to themselves in the event of failure and the perception of mistakes, whether society expects self-critical behavior from them, and last but not least, whether failure is understood as a natural part of learning or as a cause for shame. The authors’ research suggests that in certain cultures, it is self-criticism, not self-compassion, that is used as a way to regulate negative emotions and failure, functioning as a means to motivate behavioral change. According to authors Robinson et al. (2016), Western culture has doubts about the value of self-compassion and generally does not support it as a virtue, with the most common perceptions of self-compassion including, for example, viewing the construct as a sign of weakness, excessive indulgence, or selfishness, and even as undermining motivation. Montero-Marin et al. (2018) suggest that the context of broader social and cultural values also plays a role in shaping self-compassion. The authors drew on Hofstede’s (2016) model of cultural dimensions, based on which they believe that if an individual lives in a society that emphasizes individualism, competitiveness, and achievement, the person may link their self-worth precisely to performance. Such an environment can create conditions in which people react to failure with greater self-criticism, isolation, and negative self-evaluation. As a theoretical example, the authors cite the USA, which, according to Hofstede’s model, can be defined as an individualistic (promoting personal independence and personal achievements) and masculine (emphasizing a focus on performance and competitiveness) culture, where the negative components of self-compassion played a more significant role in explaining the construct of self-compassion. At the same time, however, it must be noted that a considerable part of the mentioned research is based on self-report questionnaires of self-compassion, which carry a certain risk of the tendency to appear in a better light.

If an individual finds themselves in a challenging period, for example during young adulthood, when they face many expectations from family and society (becoming independent, finding a job or a partner), a certain pressure is created upon them. According to Ferrari et al. (2018), this pressure can trigger behavior in the individual that oscillates between two extreme poles. One possible reaction to excessive expectations can be either maladaptive perfectionism or extreme disengagement, which the authors termed "giving up." This type of perfectionism pushes the individual into a constant effort to fulfill the ideals imposed on them from various sources. To a certain extent, perfectionism serves as motivation driving a person towards achieving goals; however, its pathological form is, according to authors Egan et al. (2011), associated with self-criticism, fear of mistakes, and fear of negative evaluation by others. At this level, self-compassion emerges as an alternative way of responding to one's own shortcomings and unmet expectations. Instead of self-criticism and reproach for failing to meet excessively high standards, we can try to treat ourselves with compassion, kindness, and understanding (Ferrari et al., 2018). Available research (Ferrari et al., 2018; Neff, 2023) suggests that precisely through self-compassion, individuals, especially young adults, can learn to react to their shortcomings less critically, thereby mitigating the negative consequences of their own perfectionistic concerns. Neff (2011) emphasizes the difference between self-compassion and self-esteem in this context. While self-esteem can be related to positive self-evaluation and comparison with others, self-compassion does not require a person to perceive themselves as flawless or better than others. Self-compassion can thus represent a useful way of managing perfectionistic concerns because it allows a person to achieve their goals even without constantly conditioning their self-worth on achieved results and success.

Self-compassion does not guarantee the absence of negative feelings or failure. The human experience is not about avoiding mistakes; it is about how we approach these failures and how we take care of ourselves during difficult moments. In our view, self-pity places a person in a vulnerable position full of despair, loss of hope, and unpleasant emotions in which they literally begin to drown. During self-pity, a person blames themselves and identifies with their own mistakes. A person tends to abandon themselves while experiencing difficult emotions. Unpleasant feelings such as sadness, disappointment, and frustration can evoke feelings of shame, due to which the person "wants nothing to do with themselves," which can lead to feelings of alienation from their emotions, and ultimately to alienation from themselves. Conversely, with self-compassion, the person stays with themselves, processes emotions non-judgmentally and with perspective, does not condemn themselves for them, and does not try to suppress them despite their negative charge. Unlike self-pity, self-compassion provides a moment to immerse oneself in one's own emotions, but also a subsequent emergence from them. With mental perspective, the person can pause for a moment and accept what they are currently experiencing, without perceiving their failure as defining and endless. Self-compassionate responding serves to catch and hold an emotion, but it also creates space for distance, which helps the person see the situation from another perspective. Self-pity often places the person in the role of a victim, causing the person to isolate their own experience, as well as themselves, as exclusively unique. They often forget that other people have experienced similar emotions and situations. It is precisely the awareness of common humanity that helps us approach our own emotions with acceptance, rather than harsh criticism. Ultimately, to err is human, and mistakes are a manifestation of human existence (Neff, 2023).

The difference between these constructs also emerges in their degree of control, or the extent to which a person feels they can change the current situation. As we wrote above, with self-pity, a person literally identifies with their own emotions, considering them an internal compass. For example, a person believes that because they failed an exam, they will never succeed again. In doing so, they create internal templates and define boundaries for what they can handle and achieve. In real life, these boundaries can manifest in the form of a self-fulfilling prophecy. It can be assumed that the main difference is the feeling accompanying different ways of relating to oneself. With self-pity, a person loses hope, "knowingly" placing themselves in the position of a helpless victim. Self-compassion can mobilize a person towards change because they do not perceive their own emotions and mistakes as obstacles, but as a signal of what needs to be changed. Self-pity leads us to perceive weaknesses as weak points causing us distress. Self-compassion helps to reveal these dark sides of the personality (shadow) and offers us guidance for growth and working on them. Self-pity is often associated with a feeling of weakness, while self-compassion can rather foster vulnerability, but also a person's strength. A difficult life period could be compared to a sea that a person must navigate. In this image, self-pity could represent an anchor that keeps a person close to the suffering they are experiencing and hinders forward movement, while self-compassion could represent a life jacket that keeps the person above water and provides support. It is up to us which tool we choose when struggling with the sea.

The literature points to a significant relationship between self-compassionate responding, psychological well-being, and optimal psychological functioning of an individual (Neff, 2011; Šeboková & Filipčíková, 2020). If we can empathize with our own suffering with understanding and kindness, we can overcome difficult moments and unpleasant emotions with greater ease. It is truly important that we do not ignore or condemn our feelings and failures, because through self-compassion we can get closer to ourselves and perceive suffering itself as part of the human experience. Just as important as being respectful and empathetic towards loved ones is treating ourselves with feeling and kindness. Each of us is only human, who is from time to time vulnerable and needs support.

Conclusion

In life, we cannot avoid suffering and experiencing negative emotions. Self-compassion functions towards oneself like an umbrella. It does not prevent it from raining, but it can protect us from getting even wetter. Similarly, self-compassionate responding does not guarantee the complete elimination of sadness and disappointment, yet it helps us to experience them with greater perspective and calm. During difficult moments, we sometimes tell others not to "abandon themselves." Just as important as standing by ourselves and being proud of ourselves when things are going well is standing by ourselves and not abandoning ourselves, especially in moments when we make mistakes and fail. It is precisely in such a moment that it is essential to lend a helping hand to ourselves, to persevere, and not to abandon ourselves. Self-compassion is not a manifestation of self-pity; it is a manifestation of strength requiring awareness of one's own unpleasant emotions, combined with an effort to alleviate this suffering.

Author: Mgr. Diana Stanková

Autorka pôsobí ako doktorandka na Katedre psychológie na Filozofickej fakulte, Univerzity Pavla Jozefa Šafárika v Košiciach.
Grantová podpora: VEGA 1/0145/23, APVV-23-0548

List of Bibliographic References

BARÁNKOVÁ, Martina. 2023. Approaches to the Study of Compassion. Bratislava : Comenius University in Bratislava, 2023. ISBN 978-80-223-5557-5.

BARTON, Heather. 2019. An exploration of the experiences that counsellors have of taking care of their own mental, emotional and spiritual well‐being. In Counselling and Psychotherapy Research. 2019, vol. 20, no. 3, pp. 516–524.

DALAI LAMA. 2001. An Open Heart: Practising Compassion in Everyday Life. Ed. Nicholas VREELAND. London : Hodder & Stoughton, 2001.

EGAN, Sarah. J. – WADE, Tracey. D. – SHAFRAN, Roz. 2011. Perfectionism as a transdiagnostic process: A clinical review. In Clinical Psychology Review. vol. 31, no. 2, pp. 203–212.

FERRARI, Madeleine – YAP, Keong – SCOTT, Nicole – EINSTEIN, Danielle A. – CIARROCHI, Joseph. 2018. Self-compassion moderates the perfectionism and depression link in both adolescence and adulthood. In PloS One. 2018, vol. 13, no. 2.

GILBERT, Paul. 2009. Introducing compassion-focused therapy. In Advances in Psychiatric Treatment. 2009, vol. 15, no. 3, pp. 199–208.

GILBERT, Paul. 2020. Compassion: From its evolution to a psychotherapy. In Frontiers in Psychology. 2020, vol. 11, art. no. 3123.

HALAMOVÁ, Júlia – BARÁNKOVÁ, Martina – ŠOKOVÁ, Bronislava – KORÓNIOVÁ, Jana. 2018. Consensual qualitative research on free associations for compassion and self-compassion. In Human Affairs. 2018, vol. 28, no. 3, pp. 253–270.

HOFSTEDE, Geert. 2016. Culture's consequences: Comparing values, behaviors, institutions, and organizations across nations. In Collegiate Aviation Review. 2016, vol. 34, no. 2.

CHWYL, Christina – CHEN, Patricia – ZAKI, Jamil. 2020. Beliefs about Self-Compassion: Implications for Coping and Self-Improvement. In Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin. 2020, vol. 47, no. 9, pp. 1327–1342.

JIMÉNEZ-GÓMEZ, Laura – YELA, José R. – CREGO, Antonio – MELERO-VENTOLA, Alejandra R. – GÓMEZ-MARTÍNEZ, María Á. 2022. Effectiveness of the Mindfulness-Based Stress Reduction (MBSR) vs. the Mindful Self-Compassion (MSC) Programs in Clinical and Health Psychologist Trainees. In Mindfulness. 2022, vol. 13, no. 3, pp. 584–599.

KORÓNIOVÁ, Jana – HALAMOVÁ, Júlia – TAŇKOŠOVÁ, Nikoleta. 2020. Level of self-criticism and changes in imagery among participants attending Emotion Focused Training for Self-Compassion and Self-Protection. In Československá Psychologie. 2020, vol. 64, no. 5, pp. 608–624.

MONTERO-MARIN, Jesus – KUYKEN, Willlem – CRANE, Catherine – GU, Jenny – BAER, Ruth – AL-AWAMLEH, Aida. A. – AKUTSU, Satoshi – ARAYA-VÉLIZ, Claudio – GHORBANI, Nima – CHEN, Zhuo Job – KIM, Min-Sun – MANTZIOS, Michail – SANTOS, Danilo N. Rolim – LÓPEZ, Luiz C. Serramo – TELEB, Ahmed A. – WATSON, P.J. – YAMAGUCHI, Ayano – YANG, Eunjoo – GARCIA-CAMPAYO Javier. 2018. Self-compassion and cultural values: A cross-cultural study of self-compassion using a multitrait-multimethod (MTMM) analytical procedure. In Frontiers in Psychology. 2018, vol. 9, art. 2638.

MOSER, Barbara. 2023. A Story of Self-Stigma, Shame, and a New Direction with Self-Compassion. WISE Initiative for Stigma Elimination. Available at: https://eliminatestigma.org/a-story-of-self-stigma-shame-and-a-new-direction-with-self-compassion/

NEFF, Kristin D. 2011. Self-compassion, self-esteem, and well-being. In Social and Personality Psychology Compass. 2011, vol. 5, no. 1, pp. 1–12.

NEFF, Kristin D. 2023. Self-Compassion: Theory, Method, Research, and Intervention. In Annual Review of Psychology. 2023, vol. 74, no. 1, pp. 193–218.

ROBINSON Kelley J. – MAYER Selina – ALLEN Ashley Batts – TERRY Meredith – CHILTON Ashley – Leary Mark R. 2016. Resisting self-compassion: Why are some people opposed to being kind to themselves? In Self Identity. 2016, vol. 15, no. 5, pp. 505–524

ŠEBOKOVÁ, Gabriela – FILIPČÍKOVÁ, Laura. 2020. Self-compassion in relation to optimal flourishing among psychology students. In Helping Professions. 2020, vol. 3, no. 1, pp. 41–50.

WANG, Sheila. 2005. A conceptual framework for integrating research related to the physiology of compassion and the wisdom of Buddhist teachings. In GILBERT, Paul (ed.). Compassion: Conceptualisations, research, and use in psychotherapy. New York : Routledge, 2005, pp. 75–120.